BestDaycaresNearMe
Parent Trusted
Back to New York

The Best Daycare Centers in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Discover the best licensed daycare centers in Shelter Island Heights. Quality childcare with qualified staff and safe environments.

Top Daycare Centers in Shelter Island Heights

1

The Children's Museum of the East End

CMEE

★★★★☆
4.7/5

CMEE offers a progressive, play-based preschool program that serves families across the East End, including Shelter Island. Their educational approach focuses on hands-on learning through discovery and creative expression. The facility features state-of-the-art classrooms, an outdoor nature playground, and dedicated art studios. Teachers hold early childhood education degrees and maintain low student-teacher ratios. The museum-based environment provides unique learning opportunities with interactive exhibits. Safety protocols include secure entry systems and comprehensive staff training. Parents praise the nurturing environment and strong community connections.

Experience:18 years
Reviews:48 parent reviews
376 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, NY 11932

Daycare Services:

PreschoolEarly Childhood ProgramsSummer CampEducational Workshops
2

The Hayground School

The Hayground School

★★★★☆
4.5/5

Hayground School offers an exceptional early childhood program that serves Shelter Island families with its progressive, project-based curriculum. The school emphasizes experiential learning and child-directed exploration. Their early childhood program features dedicated outdoor learning spaces, gardening activities, and arts integration. Teachers are certified in early childhood education with specialized training in developmental approaches. The school maintains excellent safety records with secure campuses and comprehensive health protocols. The extended day options and summer programs provide flexibility for working parents. The community-oriented approach and individualized attention receive high parent satisfaction marks.

Experience:27 years
Reviews:32 parent reviews
151 Mitchell Lane, Bridgehampton, NY 11932

Daycare Services:

Early Childhood ProgramElementary EducationAfter School CareSummer Camp
3

The Montessori School of Sag Harbor

Montessori School of Sag Harbor

★★★★☆
4.6/5

This AMI-recognized Montessori school serves Shelter Island families with authentic Montessori education from infancy through elementary. The school features beautifully prepared environments with authentic Montessori materials and natural lighting. Lead teachers hold AMI diplomas and advanced degrees in education. The infant and toddler programs maintain 1:4 teacher-child ratios with carefully designed spaces for developmental needs. Safety is prioritized with secure facilities, health screening protocols, and emergency preparedness training. The school's coastal location allows for nature exploration and outdoor education. Parents consistently praise the school's commitment to developing independence and lifelong learning skills in a nurturing environment.

Experience:15 years
Reviews:41 parent reviews
60 Madison Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Daycare Services:

Infant CareToddler ProgramPrimary ProgramElementary Education

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about daycare and childcare services in Shelter Island Heights, NY

What are the main types of licensed childcare options available in Shelter Island Heights, NY, and how do they differ?

In Shelter Island Heights and the broader Shelter Island area, licensed childcare options are primarily family daycare homes and group family daycare homes due to the residential, small-town nature of the community. A family daycare home is licensed to care for up to 8 children in a provider's residence, while a group family daycare can care for up to 16 children with an assistant. There are no large daycare centers on Shelter Island itself. Many families also utilize legally-exempt providers (like relatives or small-scale caregivers) or licensed programs in nearby North Fork towns like Greenport or Southold, which may involve a ferry commute. The intimate setting of in-home care is common here, offering a home-like environment but with limited slots, making early registration crucial.

How far in advance should I apply for daycare in Shelter Island Heights, and are waitlists common?

Given the extremely limited number of licensed providers on Shelter Island Heights and Shelter Island, planning is critical. For infant care, it is advisable to begin your search and get on waitlists as early as your second trimester of pregnancy, or at least 6-12 months before your needed start date. For toddler or preschool-age care, a 3-6 month lead time is recommended. Waitlists are very common and can be lengthy, especially for the few highly sought-after providers. It's also wise to get on multiple waitlists, including for licensed family daycare homes in neighboring North Fork communities accessible by ferry, as this expands your options significantly.

What is the typical cost range for full-time daycare in Shelter Island Heights, and are there any local resources for financial assistance?

Full-time daycare costs in Shelter Island Heights typically range from $1,200 to $1,800+ per month for an infant or toddler, depending on the provider's program, hours, and whether meals are included. Costs are influenced by the high cost of living on the island and the limited supply. For financial assistance, parents should explore New York State's Child Care Subsidy Program administered through the Suffolk County Department of Social Services. Eligibility is based on income and need. Additionally, some providers may offer sibling discounts. It's important to note that the limited number of providers can also limit price competition.

What are the key New York State licensing requirements I should verify when choosing a daycare provider in Shelter Island Heights?

Any licensed family or group family daycare home in Shelter Island Heights must comply with NYS Office of Children and Family Services (OCFS) regulations. Key requirements to verify include: a valid license posted visibly, background checks for all adults in the home, maximum child-to-provider ratios (e.g., 2 caregivers for 7-8 children under age 2 in a group home), safe sleep practices for infants, emergency evacuation plans, and ongoing training in topics like CPR/First Aid and Safe Sleep. You can verify a provider's license status and any history of violations through the NYS OCFS website. Always visit the home to assess safety and ask for references from other local parents.

How does the seasonal nature of Shelter Island impact childcare availability and options?

Shelter Island's status as a seasonal summer destination significantly impacts childcare. Many year-round providers may have limited openings as they sometimes prioritize the children of local year-round families. In the summer, demand surges with an influx of seasonal residents and workers, which can lead to temporary summer programs or camps, but these are often for older children and may not cover infant/toddler care. Conversely, some year-round providers may have more availability in the off-season (fall through spring). Planning for consistent, year-round care requires securing a spot with a provider who operates 12 months a year and understanding their policy on holding spots if you are a seasonal resident.

Nearby Cities

Explore daycare options in cities near Shelter Island Heights: